Return to CreateDebate.commamoffat • Join this debate community

Ms Moffat's Class


Yasmeenmehdi's Waterfall RSS

This personal waterfall shows you all of Yasmeenmehdi's arguments, looking across every debate.
1 point

corporal punishment in schools is illegal in 31 out of 50 states for a reason. It is not at all effective, only cheap and takes less time. Would you rather save time by abusing a child? Or properly teach/“rehabilitate” a child and make them a better person?

Supporting Evidence: corporal punishment in schools (www.al.com)
1 point

Spanking also happens to show more bias than other forms of punishment. In one study, the numbers indicated that boys got punished more often than girls, and “blacks” were punished more often than the rest of the kids.

Supporting Evidence: nbc news (www.nbcnews.com)
1 point

There was a paddling case in Georgia where a five-year-old boy was abused. On the site, there are many other pieces of evidence. "Some argue that spanking can help drive down a child's IQ or ability to learn. Others say it triggers more aggressiveness. And child welfare advocates warn that corporal punishment — along with harsh but non-physical discipline — is often applied disproportionately to students with disabilities and those who are black, raising the chances that they will fall behind in school."

Supporting Evidence: georgia paddling case (www.nbcnews.com)
1 point

Corporal punishment will make the school like a violent environment and it is a form of child abuse.

Supporting Evidence: child abuse !!!! (www.procon.org)
1 point

Of course discipline is an important aspect, but some people feel like it is overrated. On a site about self-discipline, it was commented that one doesn’t really need self-discipline as long as they have the right motivation. Studies show that spanking lowers a child’s self-esteem. If a child is spanked constantly, the only proper/instinctive motivation they will have is to not get spanked.

Supporting Evidence: self discipline (www.becomingminimalist.com)
1 point

Although it might take less time out of their lessons to give a lecture, studies show that students who are corporally punished in school “perform significantly worse executive functioning”

Supporting Evidence: science daily (www.sciencedaily.com)
1 point

Yes, I understand your point, but a lecture is quite effective and doesn’t need to cause any kids harm. Also, where spanking a child with a paddle is cheap, a lecture is completely free.



Results Per Page: [12] [24] [48] [96]